Protestantism leaves us with this dilemma. There is no way around it. The exegetical battles have been raging for 10 years plus, and neither side triumphs. All I can say is this:

Gay Christians must do one of two things:

a. Show that the texts don’t mean what they say, but have an entirely different meaning that blesses homosexual sex as holy.

or.

b. They must construct a cultural critique that makes the view that homosexuality is sin parallel to the view that slavery is acceptable.

Either one is an impossible road, in my opinion, and can only be done with irreparable damage to the Biblical approach and theology that is needed to sustain the faith.

One note: Hebrews 13:4 makes it clear that there are two options in sex: Marriage or celibacy. I do not agree that one must announce reorientation to heterosexual desire to be a Christian. One is simply a new creation in Christ.

Some also claim to be Roman Catholics…what is the difference whether you are a Protestant who is twisting or devaluing scripture or a Roman Catholic who is ignoring tradition?

You said….”Gay Christians must do one of two things:

a. Show that the texts don’t mean what they say, but have an entirely different meaning that blesses homosexual sex as holy.”

They are attempting to do this with “pro-gay theology”, and sadly, many churches are buying into it.

I’ve really enjoyed this impromptu series you’ve got going here. Did you read Mark Roberts’ series on Christian tolerance and homosexuality? It’s on his website. Great stuff. Keep up the good work.

Matt Crash!